Resomation vs Cremation | Phaneuf
Call Our Care Team: 1-800-742-6383

Resomation vs Cremation

Over the last several months, resomation and cremation have been hot topics in our local media (no pun intended).  In case you have missed the debate, a local Manchester funeral director wants to be the first funeral home in the country to commercially offer resomation.  Resomation, otherwise known as alkaline hydrolysis, is a process that uses high pressure heated water and acid to reduce the body to calcium phosphate. Resomation is being touted nationwide as an eco-friendly alternatve to cremation and has been referred to as bio-cremation.  It seems like anything that is perceived to be eco-friendly automatically gets the green light.  And this was initially the case with resomation.  The NH Statehouse approved the resomation process and was going to regulate it as a form of cremation.  But the State Senate recently reversed the decision and decided that resomation has not place in New Hampshire.

Do I agree with the decision?  Yes and No.  While I have been interviewed on NH Public Radio, WMUR and have been quoted in the Union Leader, Concord Monitor and in several funeral service trade magazines about my opposition to resomation as a eco-friendly alternative to cremation, I am not opposed to an individual’s right to be able to select resomation as a option if they so desire.

My major problem with this entire issue is the fact that resomation was initially going to be regulated by the State just like cremation.  And the resomation process was already being marketed as a form of cremation that was better for the environment.  However, the resomation process has very few similarities to the cremation process.  I am also not convinced that resomation has any more or less impact on the environment than cremation.  While the resomation process has no airborn emissions, there is a significant electrical demand to heat the water.  In NH, a good percentage of our electricity is generated by coal burning plants.  So, one needs to take a look at the entire resomation process from beginning to end to determine it’s true environmental impact.

You know my opinion on resomation but what is yours.

  • What are your cremation options?

    Every day, the cremation options grow in the United States and around the globe, but misconceptions remain. Some believe it’s just a cremation, no service, no memorial, no opportunity for friends and family to sayRead more

  • Smart Sustainability for Cremation Business

    A quarter century ago when I started in the funeral and cremation business, burials accounted for 85% of industry business, though in NH a slightly higher 20% of families chose cremation for their loved ones.Read more

  • Is cremation jewelry creepy?

    Cremation will soon outpace traditional burial as the end-of-life choice for most Americans. The growth of cremation has come with a variety of options for cremated remains, the granular particles left after the cremation process.Read more

  • What is Direct Cremation?

    Nearly 80% of New Hampshire residents choose cremation instead of a traditional funeral service, and the National Funeral Directors Association (NFDA) predicts that the national cremation rate will reach 85% by the year 2035. ThereRead more

  • How Cremation Works

    More and more people are asking about how cremation works when they start thinking about end-of-life planning. Cremation has become a more-economical approach to a burial, and that is one of the top reasons itRead more

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to Our Blog

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.